How to score PPC agency proposals: an evaluation matrix with weights, questions and warning signs

Abstract orange illustration on a dark background: silhouette of a person with a magnifying glass, representing choosing who manages PPC. News topic: “How to score PPC agency proposals: an evaluation matrix with weights, questions and warning signs”
In short

A PPC proposal evaluation matrix has eight criteria with weights, for example: business understanding (20%), measurement and reports (15%), AI control and compliance (15%), transparency and ownership (15%), approach and strategy (15%), team and references (10%), contract and exit (5%), price (5%). Each criterion scores 0 to 5 with questions and evidence. Weights and criteria are suggestions; adjust them to your case. In 2026, give real weight to AI control (Meta and Google make the advertiser responsible) and to knowledge of changes (for example bidding since 17 August, the February 2027 calendar).

Why a matrix

Without criteria, you decide by the best salesperson, sympathy or price. A matrix forces you to decide beforehand what matters, score with evidence and justify the choice before partners or management. It also helps see, afterwards, whether the decision was good.

The matrix doesn’t decide for you; it organises the decision.

The eight criteria and suggested weights

1) Business understanding (20%). 2) Measurement and reports (15%). 3) AI control and compliance (15%). 4) Transparency and ownership (15%). 5) Approach and strategy (15%). 6) Team and references (10%). 7) Contract and exit (5%). 8) Price (5%). Price weighs little because differences in scope and quality are usually bigger than those in price, but it may rise if budget is critical.

Adjust weights to your risk: a regulated sector weighs compliance more.

Two panels side by side, the right one highlighted in orange, illustrating a comparison. It represents: Suggested weights for the eight criteria of a PPC proposal evaluation matrix

PPC proposal evaluation matrix

Suggested weights

  • Business 20%
  • Measurement, AI and transparency 15% each
  • Strategy 15%

Others

  • Team and references 10%
  • Contract and exit 5%
  • Price 5%

How to score from 0 to 5

0: no answer. 1: vague answer. 2: generic answer, no examples. 3: reasonable answer with some examples. 4: concrete answer, with examples from your account or sector. 5: concrete answer, with proof and documented process. Score each criterion per person and add up; discuss differences.

The difference between 3 and 5 is in proof.

Criterion 3: AI control and compliance

Questions: which AI features do you switch on and how do you control them? Who approves texts, images and videos? How is it recorded? How do you handle customer data and consent? According to PPC Land, Meta and Google make the advertiser responsible for what AI creates, so the answer should have process, not just intent. Ask for an example approval policy.

An answer of “AI takes care of everything” scores 0 or 1.

Large orange quotation marks on a dark background, with abstract text lines, illustrating the quote: “It's better to lose a candidate than to gain a problem.”
It's better to lose a candidate than to gain a problem.

Criterion 2: measurement and reports

Questions: which business results do you measure (enquiries, sales, margin)? How do you connect the CRM? How do you separate bidding value from revenue? What report do you deliver? How do you flag platform changes? Ask for a sample report. Whoever only shows clicks and impressions scores low. Whoever explains the difference between platform revenue and business revenue scores high.

Measurement is the basis of any future decision.

Criterion 4: transparency and ownership

Questions: in whose name will the account, pixel and data be? What access do I have? Do you deliver exports? What happens on exit? How do you charge (fees, percentage of spend, platform commissions)? A transparent provider answers without hesitation. If the account stays in the agency’s name, score 0 until corrected.

Transparency is a factor of trust and protection.

Warning signs that cancel points

Promises of guaranteed results; position guarantee; refusal of account access; clicks-only reports; long contracts without exit; ignorance of recent changes; and pressure to decide quickly. A single one of these signs may justify excluding the candidate. Record them in the matrix.

It’s better to lose a candidate than to gain a problem.

Summary and questions for you

Summary: eight criteria with weights, 0-to-5 scale with proof, questions per criterion, warning signs and team discussion. Questions for you: which criteria weigh most in our case? Who scores? What proof do we ask for? Which warning signs are eliminatory?

If you want to set up your PPC proposal evaluation matrix, with weights and questions adapted to your sector, I can help create it.

Illustrative scoring example

Hypothetical example, not real: two candidates, A and B. A scores 4 on business understanding and 5 on transparency, but 2 on AI control. B scores 3 on understanding, 3 on transparency and 4 on AI control. With the weights above, A adds more points, but the AI weakness becomes visible and can be corrected in writing before signing.

The matrix doesn’t remove judgement; it shows where judgement should focus.

How to decide when scores are close

If two candidates end within five percentage points, ask for a one-hour working session on your real account, with the same data for both. Observe how they ask, how they explain and how they react to objections. Record the conclusions in the same matrix and decide as a team.

A practical session is worth more than a third presentation.

Reviewing the matrix after hiring

Use the matrix again at 90 days and then every quarter, with the same criteria and real evidence: reports delivered, decisions explained, business results, respect for AI and approval rules. If a criterion drops persistently, schedule a meeting to correct it before it becomes a problem.

Ongoing assessment protects both sides of the relationship.

Frequently asked questions

What weight to give price?

Little, by default (for example 5% to 10%): differences in scope and quality usually weigh more. Raise it if budget is critical.

Can I use the matrix to assess the current agency?

Yes: use the same criteria to assess the current relationship, quarterly.

Who should score?

Two to three people, independently, then discuss. Include whoever decides the budget.

Sources consulted

Keep reading

Contacto rápido

Quer falar sobre as suas campanhas?

Deixe uma nota curta. Respondo em 1 dia útil.